MOVIE REVIEW: “EXPELLED: NO INTELLIGENCE ALLOWED”

Tues. 01/06/2009
The documentary “Expelled” is out on DVD and Blu Ray now. I have checked it out, and am going to share my observations and thoughts with those who care to see them.
The film is narrated and hosted by Ben Stein. He is best known as the high school teacher in “Ferris Bueller’s Day Off” who continually repeats himself: “Anyone? Anyone? Anyone? Bueller? Bueller? Bueller?”. Everyone has copied this line and used it in their own comedy. Right? Don’t tell me I am the only one that steals that line.
Anyway, the film is a documentary that is seeking to communicate the message that academic freedom in our institutions of learning is being suppressed by those in charge. The freedom to hold to your own views could potentially bring about consequences, such as the loss of your job and the destruction of your reputation. The students are taught dogmatically that Darwinian evolution is the ONLY acceptable philosophy. If you observe a hole or an inconsistency in the theory, pretend that you do not see it. Ask no questions of it. Offer no criticisms of it. Just blindly receive it by faith. A comparison is made between this method of teaching and the indoctrination camps of some pretty bloody regimes in world history.
The film shows excerpts of interviews with university professors who have been terminated because they have, while teaching biology or a related subject, pointed out in passing that Darwin’s theory is not without some very serious problems. They went on to instruct their young people as to what those problems are specifically. Because they have done the duty of making the students aware of the existence of these issues, steps were taken to silence their voices. Thus, the information that students have access to is being restricted by the powers that be in the world of academia.
There are also excerpts of interviews with well-known professors and thinkers who are devout anti-theists. These interviews are very revealing, because you can see that the forwarding of this very shaky theory (Darwinism) is energized and pushed forward by some strong underlying philosophies and presuppositions. The terminology that they use about Creation Science and the people that hold to it is absolutely nasty. I’ll put it to you like this: If such wording was used about any other group of people, these folks would be viewed as bigoted and in need of tolerance education and diversity training. But since it is used of Intelligent Design people, it is acceptable in their eyes.
As far as they are concerned, religious people are like big children who never stopped believing in goblins, ghoulies, elves, leprechauns, etc. They clearly hold to a Platonic dichotomy or distinction – a wall of separation – which separates the realm of the religious from the realm of science. They hold to ideas that religion and science are mutually exclusive. In their eyes you can be a man of one, or a man of the other. But you cannot be a man of both simultaneously.
One of the more powerful scenes is when Stein (who is Jewish) visiting a concentration camp that has since become a museum and memorial. An interview with a lady there reveals how commonly known it is outside of America in other places that Hitler and his Naziistic philosophy owe a great deal to Darwinian evolution and philosophical naturalism. The holocaust was Germany living out “The Origin of the Species” to its fullest conclusion. The liquidation of the “unfit” so that the “fit” could survive and move humankind forward was one of the dominant ideas in Hitler’s “Mien Kampf”

http://search.barnesandnoble.com/Mein-Kampf/Adolf-Hitler/e/9780395925034/?itm=1

He was seeking to help humankind evolve to the next level by inserting himself into the process and pushing it along. Thus, Darwinism has an unpaid bill of 6 million lives according to the thesis of this film.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_darwinism

The link is shown between Nazi eugenics in Germany and Planned Parenthood in America. It does highlight how Margaret Sanger, Planned Parenthood’s founder, wanted to get involved with and restrict the reproductive rights of those whom she viewed as “unfit to breed”. Again, Darwinism being applied to daily life as a philosophy. In this film, Darwinism as a world and life view takes you down the road to a very dark place filled with abortion, infanticide, and euthanasia.

The movie has both pros and cons.

The pros are #1 that after having to endure documentaries by the likes of Michael Moore and such, finally a documentary is out there that has taken time to get its facts right. Finally there is a documentary whose goal is to build up as opposed to tear down.

#2 I can tell that money was spent on it, as Ben Stein often travels to different states and even to different countries to interview authorities on this subject.

#3 I feel that the message, which is a call to action – it is a call to question and a call to think – is very relevant in our time in which education has become little more than indoctrination. Kids who question the status quo usually wind up in detention until they either conform or keep quiet. There is a mass exodus taking place as more parents become hip to this and rush to get their kids into home schooling and private school.

#4 Getting a movie like this into the mainstream box office is a coup, especially in a Hollywood dominated by socialists, one world multi-culturalists, and homosexuals.

#5 Ben Stein is to be applauded for his courage. He has put his career on the line. He is now a marked man, sure to be black-listed in many circles in which he once enjoyed membership. He has put convictions before reputation, and is willing to become unpopular for those convictions.

The cons are that #1 For those who have been familiar with the Naturalism / Supernaturalism or Creation / Evolution debate down through the years, there is not much new here. We have heard or experienced anti-theistic bigotry in education and employment before. We have read of the link between Darwin, Hitler, Stalin, etc. before. We have seen the weaknesses of Darwinian theory before. We have seen atheists and evolutionists turn red, shout, and become emotional about this before – all while calling us irrational. We have lived that many times over. In other words, while it put in film format some of the things we have always known about and experienced, not much new ground has been broken. But through the eyes of someone who has never seen this before, this film might look different than it did to me.

#2 One cannot control how a discussion unfolds or develops. So this was not within the realm of the filmmaker’s control. But I am just throwing it out there. There is a lot of use of specific jargon and terminology that only those who have read up on this subject will understand. But to those who are looking at this subject for the first time, since no effort is ever made to define these terms, it may be difficult for the average Joe to follow at times. This will limit the movie’s appeal to a niche crowd, those specifically trained with knowledge of the terminology involved. In other words, the film is not at the level of “Beginner”. It is at the level of “Intermediate”. So “Beginners” at this subject may be lost at times during their viewing of this film. A kindergartener cannot do algebra because they have not yet worked their way up to that point.

Overall, I give this film my recommendation. It brings things to the forefront that people are thinking about but are afraid to talk about. It encourages open dialogue, against the current way of doing things which seeks to silence open dialogue and force-feed people only one view. It is polarizing. You will either really love and feel inspired by it, or you will violently oppose all that it stands for and be angered by it. But if you are a student of the issues involved in Creationism vs. Evolution, or if you are a student of civil rights and academic freedom, this is a can’t miss movie.

As far as documentaries go, is it the best one that I have ever seen?  No.  But it ranks right up there!

 

 

bjshanley@hotmail.com

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Published in: on January 6, 2009 at 5:55 pm Leave a Comment

The URI to TrackBack this entry is: http://brianjamesshanley.wordpress.com/2009/01/06/movie-review-expelled-no-intelligence-allowed/trackback/

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Leave a Comment